{ "scope": "Complete eight-case reduced mechanical matrix and explicitly substituted thermal references.", "label": "Process demonstration\u2014unvalidated engineering estimates.", "basis_sha256": "9324327567b04bf73f35460a5e6ea9db0c7c304bc5d5181ceaa29044a5df716f", "cases": { "fresh-000": { "id": "fresh-000", "classification": "Native calculation with provisional inputs", "closure_percent": 0, "stiffness_N_per_mm": 50, "elements": 100, "native_complete": true, "finite_fields": true, "deck_sha256": "5b66269b8eba1b8cc2aa9c4be2bcc3ee4f9f27bc3067a54bf94be29780366e38", "native_files": { "dat": "5a94f7d31dc4cc327981f503c9b9cee0c5343f042a9a2221bf67713a8d9e691c", "sta": "01e324ec0ea28f4d1fd7f5e2da1277af53812b873e218be1604c17a4c8e4990d", "frd": "bdcb44e75f13928701345e37433e8636ccacaf7ae1a3f300e3c77ee0f7fa8f7d" }, "midpoint_displacement_mm": 0.0, "midpoint_error_mm": 0.0, "minimum_nodal_gap_mm": 3.1, "gap_target_error_mm": 0.0, "grid_anchor_reaction_x_N": 0.0, "grid_force_magnitude_N": 0.0, "printed_midpoint_RF_x_N": 0.0, "actuator_reaction_x_N": null, "global_equilibrium_status": "not established", "end_reactions_x_N": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "total_force_x_N": 0.0, "force_balance_relative": 0.0, "spring_check_absolute_N": 0.0, "spring_check_relative": 0.0, "maximum_absolute_axial_integration_point_stress_MPa": 0.0, "stress_points": 1600, "contact_pressure": null, "DNBR": null, "DNBR_requirement": "not established", "limits": [ "rod-to-rod contact and load redistribution", "grid strap interference", "spring/dimple travel/yield", "local cladding contact stress", "coolant/internal-pressure stresses", "pellet interaction", "creep and irradiation constitutive response", "thermal gradients" ], "added_axial_integration_point_stress_MPa": 0.0, "thermal_references": [ { "test": "166-9", "p_MPa": 16.5474175036032, "inlet_C": 295.0, "mass_flux_kg_m2s": 2759.927844455419, "measured_CHF_MW_m2": 1.1703531664183908, "author_critical_power_MW": 2.5226, "geometry": "straight", "classification": "Published experimental/simulation reference", "source_url": "https://github.com/roman-mukin/HTRF-rod-bowing/tree/54121540d80e6d587d17b801b369b5fc9b56c6e1", "illustrative_reference_scaling_index": 1.3971737056957163, "index_classification": "Unvalidated transferred estimate; not study DNBR" }, { "test": "166-8", "p_MPa": 16.5474175036032, "inlet_C": 291.3333333333333, "mass_flux_kg_m2s": 3349.8878505183707, "measured_CHF_MW_m2": 1.3785561555925523, "author_critical_power_MW": 2.9714, "geometry": "straight", "classification": "Published experimental/simulation reference", "source_url": "https://github.com/roman-mukin/HTRF-rod-bowing/tree/54121540d80e6d587d17b801b369b5fc9b56c6e1", "illustrative_reference_scaling_index": 1.6457275185688092, "index_classification": "Unvalidated transferred estimate; not study DNBR" }, { "test": "166-7", "p_MPa": 14.4789903156528, "inlet_C": 294.6111111111111, "mass_flux_kg_m2s": 3356.6690000133476, "measured_CHF_MW_m2": 1.1987444831239584, "author_critical_power_MW": 2.5838, "geometry": "straight", "classification": "Published experimental/simulation reference", "source_url": "https://github.com/roman-mukin/HTRF-rod-bowing/tree/54121540d80e6d587d17b801b369b5fc9b56c6e1", "illustrative_reference_scaling_index": 1.431067407451138, "index_classification": "Unvalidated transferred estimate; not study DNBR" } ], "thermal_transfer_limit": "HTRF 85% closure is a disclosed proxy for 80%. Preserve all source P/T/G and geometry differences. Report both contact arrangements separately.", "nominal_study_heat_flux_W_m2": 837657.5952205018 }, "fresh-050": { "id": "fresh-050", "classification": "Native calculation with provisional inputs", "closure_percent": 50, "stiffness_N_per_mm": 50, "elements": 100, "native_complete": true, "finite_fields": true, "deck_sha256": "bc1621967af2dfc8554ddf60da10f9349ce298173b9d40a9a7516197240b2996", "native_files": { "dat": "3d5f3dad701874dd0eac54edb3042f3bac2c19e73affdcc00d63fbddd0b1b7fa", "sta": "01e324ec0ea28f4d1fd7f5e2da1277af53812b873e218be1604c17a4c8e4990d", "frd": "aceba3600af414bc0cb8d4dd72615f5a21d0f28c76ed9fb4ef24e45e3ec6ab17" }, "midpoint_displacement_mm": 1.55, "midpoint_error_mm": 0.0, "minimum_nodal_gap_mm": 1.55, "gap_target_error_mm": 0.0, "grid_anchor_reaction_x_N": -77.5, "grid_force_magnitude_N": 77.5, "printed_midpoint_RF_x_N": 0.9215696, "actuator_reaction_x_N": null, "global_equilibrium_status": "not established", "end_reactions_x_N": [ -0.4607848, -0.4607848 ], "total_force_x_N": -77.50000000061067, "force_balance_relative": 0.976770024013072, "spring_check_absolute_N": 0.0, "spring_check_relative": 0.0, "maximum_absolute_axial_integration_point_stress_MPa": 6.406824, "stress_points": 1600, "contact_pressure": null, "DNBR": null, "DNBR_requirement": "not established", "limits": [ "rod-to-rod contact and load redistribution", "grid strap interference", "spring/dimple travel/yield", "local cladding contact stress", "coolant/internal-pressure stresses", "pellet interaction", "creep and irradiation constitutive response", "thermal gradients" ], "added_axial_integration_point_stress_MPa": 6.406824, "thermal_references": [ { "test": "170-4", "p_MPa": 16.65083886300072, "inlet_C": 292.8333333333333, "mass_flux_kg_m2s": 2713.816027889579, "measured_CHF_MW_m2": 1.1356526682226975, "author_critical_power_MW": 2.4478, "geometry": "partial bow, 50 percent remaining gap", "classification": "Published experimental/simulation reference", "source_url": "https://github.com/roman-mukin/HTRF-rod-bowing/tree/54121540d80e6d587d17b801b369b5fc9b56c6e1", "illustrative_reference_scaling_index": 1.3557480702168678, "index_classification": "Unvalidated transferred estimate; not study DNBR" }, { "test": "170-5", "p_MPa": 16.512943717137357, "inlet_C": 293.8333333333333, "mass_flux_kg_m2s": 3374.2999887002857, "measured_CHF_MW_m2": 1.3249281129264803, "author_critical_power_MW": 2.8558, "geometry": "partial bow, 50 percent remaining gap", "classification": "Published experimental/simulation reference", "source_url": "https://github.com/roman-mukin/HTRF-rod-bowing/tree/54121540d80e6d587d17b801b369b5fc9b56c6e1", "illustrative_reference_scaling_index": 1.581706081919679, "index_classification": "Unvalidated transferred estimate; not study DNBR" }, { "test": "170-6", "p_MPa": 14.4789903156528, "inlet_C": 296.1666666666667, "mass_flux_kg_m2s": 3359.3814598113377, "measured_CHF_MW_m2": 1.2113628461042107, "author_critical_power_MW": 2.611, "geometry": "partial bow, 50 percent remaining gap", "classification": "Published experimental/simulation reference", "source_url": "https://github.com/roman-mukin/HTRF-rod-bowing/tree/54121540d80e6d587d17b801b369b5fc9b56c6e1", "illustrative_reference_scaling_index": 1.4461312748979924, "index_classification": "Unvalidated transferred estimate; not study DNBR" } ], "thermal_transfer_limit": "HTRF 85% closure is a disclosed proxy for 80%. Preserve all source P/T/G and geometry differences. Report both contact arrangements separately.", "nominal_study_heat_flux_W_m2": 837657.5952205018 }, "fresh-080": { "id": "fresh-080", "classification": "Native calculation with provisional inputs", "closure_percent": 80, "stiffness_N_per_mm": 50, "elements": 100, "native_complete": true, "finite_fields": true, "deck_sha256": "32fefb63fd01941c641041aaa9c032d0a68b4a9e4037e8cfd4ae77a1d772eae7", "native_files": { "dat": "890691882799ee84324189a95be6384c1f441b6e8a3535450b69ff1e428f4bf0", "sta": "01e324ec0ea28f4d1fd7f5e2da1277af53812b873e218be1604c17a4c8e4990d", "frd": "539ad6e30e0ea0926bc39f32d72f91090730261720b402d33b5e16d17147c013" }, "midpoint_displacement_mm": 2.48, "midpoint_error_mm": 0.0, "minimum_nodal_gap_mm": 0.6200000000000001, "gap_target_error_mm": 0.0, "grid_anchor_reaction_x_N": -124.0, "grid_force_magnitude_N": 124.0, "printed_midpoint_RF_x_N": 1.474511, "actuator_reaction_x_N": null, "global_equilibrium_status": "not established", "end_reactions_x_N": [ -0.7372557, -0.7372557 ], "total_force_x_N": -124.00000040181621, "force_balance_relative": 0.9767700296406471, "spring_check_absolute_N": 0.0, "spring_check_relative": 0.0, "maximum_absolute_axial_integration_point_stress_MPa": 10.25092, "stress_points": 1600, "contact_pressure": null, "DNBR": null, "DNBR_requirement": "not established", "limits": [ "rod-to-rod contact and load redistribution", "grid strap interference", "spring/dimple travel/yield", "local cladding contact stress", "coolant/internal-pressure stresses", "pellet interaction", "creep and irradiation constitutive response", "thermal gradients" ], "added_axial_integration_point_stress_MPa": 10.25092, "thermal_references": [ { "test": "169-6", "p_MPa": 16.5474175036032, "inlet_C": 292.3333333333333, "mass_flux_kg_m2s": 2991.843157183614, "measured_CHF_MW_m2": 1.154580212693076, "author_critical_power_MW": 2.4886, "geometry": "partial bow, 15 percent remaining gap", "classification": "Published experimental/simulation reference", "source_url": "https://github.com/roman-mukin/HTRF-rod-bowing/tree/54121540d80e6d587d17b801b369b5fc9b56c6e1", "illustrative_reference_scaling_index": 1.3783438713871492, "index_classification": "Unvalidated transferred estimate; not study DNBR" }, { "test": "169-8", "p_MPa": 14.58241167505032, "inlet_C": 293.72222222222223, "mass_flux_kg_m2s": 3382.4373680942576, "measured_CHF_MW_m2": 1.2018990738690214, "author_critical_power_MW": 2.5906, "geometry": "partial bow, 15 percent remaining gap", "classification": "Published experimental/simulation reference", "source_url": "https://github.com/roman-mukin/HTRF-rod-bowing/tree/54121540d80e6d587d17b801b369b5fc9b56c6e1", "illustrative_reference_scaling_index": 1.4348333743128516, "index_classification": "Unvalidated transferred estimate; not study DNBR" }, { "test": "169-7", "p_MPa": 16.58189129006904, "inlet_C": 295.27777777777777, "mass_flux_kg_m2s": 3397.355896983206, "measured_CHF_MW_m2": 1.306000568456102, "author_critical_power_MW": 2.815, "geometry": "partial bow, 15 percent remaining gap", "classification": "Published experimental/simulation reference", "source_url": "https://github.com/roman-mukin/HTRF-rod-bowing/tree/54121540d80e6d587d17b801b369b5fc9b56c6e1", "illustrative_reference_scaling_index": 1.5591102807493977, "index_classification": "Unvalidated transferred estimate; not study DNBR" } ], "thermal_transfer_limit": "HTRF 85% closure is a disclosed proxy for 80%. Preserve all source P/T/G and geometry differences. Report both contact arrangements separately.", "nominal_study_heat_flux_W_m2": 837657.5952205018 }, "fresh-100": { "id": "fresh-100", "classification": "Native calculation with provisional inputs", "closure_percent": 100, "stiffness_N_per_mm": 50, "elements": 100, "native_complete": true, "finite_fields": true, "deck_sha256": "1a6e04c3ac3a3a8cb97ae567634e21679b32c0233b88320e9052fd0d465d736a", "native_files": { "dat": "aaff63503471b573552d8210f66a013f9c628504a0a71235fb271088dbf2815a", "sta": "01e324ec0ea28f4d1fd7f5e2da1277af53812b873e218be1604c17a4c8e4990d", "frd": "6b5ac69d3e221e2ca3501ddc0f66fc4bdc8830d7311dbbba71cddb55c68c4d00" }, "midpoint_displacement_mm": 3.1, "midpoint_error_mm": 0.0, "minimum_nodal_gap_mm": 0.0, "gap_target_error_mm": 0.0, "grid_anchor_reaction_x_N": -155.0, "grid_force_magnitude_N": 155.0, "printed_midpoint_RF_x_N": 1.843139, "actuator_reaction_x_N": null, "global_equilibrium_status": "not established", "end_reactions_x_N": [ -0.9215696, -0.9215696 ], "total_force_x_N": -155.00000020122133, "force_balance_relative": 0.9767700265044909, "spring_check_absolute_N": 0.0, "spring_check_relative": 0.0, "maximum_absolute_axial_integration_point_stress_MPa": 12.81365, "stress_points": 1600, "contact_pressure": null, "DNBR": null, "DNBR_requirement": "not established", "limits": [ "rod-to-rod contact and load redistribution", "grid strap interference", "spring/dimple travel/yield", "local cladding contact stress", "coolant/internal-pressure stresses", "pellet interaction", "creep and irradiation constitutive response", "thermal gradients" ], "added_axial_integration_point_stress_MPa": 12.81365, "thermal_references": [ { "test": "167-5", "p_MPa": 16.5474175036032, "inlet_C": 291.3888888888889, "mass_flux_kg_m2s": 2750.434235162452, "measured_CHF_MW_m2": 0.9621501772442297, "author_critical_power_MW": 2.0738, "geometry": "contact arrangement 167", "classification": "Published experimental/simulation reference", "source_url": "https://github.com/roman-mukin/HTRF-rod-bowing/tree/54121540d80e6d587d17b801b369b5fc9b56c6e1", "illustrative_reference_scaling_index": 1.1486198928226241, "index_classification": "Unvalidated transferred estimate; not study DNBR" }, { "test": "167-6", "p_MPa": 16.5474175036032, "inlet_C": 288.0, "mass_flux_kg_m2s": 3465.16739193297, "measured_CHF_MW_m2": 1.100952170027004, "author_critical_power_MW": 2.373, "geometry": "contact arrangement 167", "classification": "Published experimental/simulation reference", "source_url": "https://github.com/roman-mukin/HTRF-rod-bowing/tree/54121540d80e6d587d17b801b369b5fc9b56c6e1", "illustrative_reference_scaling_index": 1.314322434738019, "index_classification": "Unvalidated transferred estimate; not study DNBR" }, { "test": "167-7", "p_MPa": 14.4789903156528, "inlet_C": 297.6111111111111, "mass_flux_kg_m2s": 3378.368678397272, "measured_CHF_MW_m2": 1.1451164404578869, "author_critical_power_MW": 2.4682, "geometry": "contact arrangement 167", "classification": "Published experimental/simulation reference", "source_url": "https://github.com/roman-mukin/HTRF-rod-bowing/tree/54121540d80e6d587d17b801b369b5fc9b56c6e1", "illustrative_reference_scaling_index": 1.3670459708020086, "index_classification": "Unvalidated transferred estimate; not study DNBR" }, { "test": "168-5", "p_MPa": 16.58189129006904, "inlet_C": 295.05555555555554, "mass_flux_kg_m2s": 2753.146694960442, "measured_CHF_MW_m2": 0.9558409957541036, "author_critical_power_MW": 2.0602, "geometry": "contact arrangement 168", "classification": "Published experimental/simulation reference", "source_url": "https://github.com/roman-mukin/HTRF-rod-bowing/tree/54121540d80e6d587d17b801b369b5fc9b56c6e1", "illustrative_reference_scaling_index": 1.141087959099197, "index_classification": "Unvalidated transferred estimate; not study DNBR" }, { "test": "168-8", "p_MPa": 14.4789903156528, "inlet_C": 293.1111111111111, "mass_flux_kg_m2s": 3383.7935979932527, "measured_CHF_MW_m2": 1.233444981319652, "author_critical_power_MW": 2.6586, "geometry": "contact arrangement 168", "classification": "Published experimental/simulation reference", "source_url": "https://github.com/roman-mukin/HTRF-rod-bowing/tree/54121540d80e6d587d17b801b369b5fc9b56c6e1", "illustrative_reference_scaling_index": 1.472493042929987, "index_classification": "Unvalidated transferred estimate; not study DNBR" }, { "test": "168-6", "p_MPa": 16.5474175036032, "inlet_C": 293.77777777777777, "mass_flux_kg_m2s": 3401.4245866801916, "measured_CHF_MW_m2": 1.0914883977918148, "author_critical_power_MW": 2.3526, "geometry": "contact arrangement 168", "classification": "Published experimental/simulation reference", "source_url": "https://github.com/roman-mukin/HTRF-rod-bowing/tree/54121540d80e6d587d17b801b369b5fc9b56c6e1", "illustrative_reference_scaling_index": 1.3030245341528786, "index_classification": "Unvalidated transferred estimate; not study DNBR" } ], "thermal_transfer_limit": "HTRF 85% closure is a disclosed proxy for 80%. Preserve all source P/T/G and geometry differences. Report both contact arrangements separately.", "nominal_study_heat_flux_W_m2": 837657.5952205018 }, "softened-000": { "id": "softened-000", "classification": "Native calculation with provisional inputs", "closure_percent": 0, "stiffness_N_per_mm": 20, "elements": 100, "native_complete": true, "finite_fields": true, "deck_sha256": "95e6d37f23d69d08ef56cdd313de22b80f3b647b41daeceb71d06577361acd55", "native_files": { "dat": "5a94f7d31dc4cc327981f503c9b9cee0c5343f042a9a2221bf67713a8d9e691c", "sta": "01e324ec0ea28f4d1fd7f5e2da1277af53812b873e218be1604c17a4c8e4990d", "frd": "9a919687c67cbee34b5c5cead9a297c5edc698a423a0f274a0c63f0b64a69954" }, "midpoint_displacement_mm": 0.0, "midpoint_error_mm": 0.0, "minimum_nodal_gap_mm": 3.1, "gap_target_error_mm": 0.0, "grid_anchor_reaction_x_N": 0.0, "grid_force_magnitude_N": 0.0, "printed_midpoint_RF_x_N": 0.0, "actuator_reaction_x_N": null, "global_equilibrium_status": "not established", "end_reactions_x_N": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "total_force_x_N": 0.0, "force_balance_relative": 0.0, "spring_check_absolute_N": 0.0, "spring_check_relative": 0.0, "maximum_absolute_axial_integration_point_stress_MPa": 0.0, "stress_points": 1600, "contact_pressure": null, "DNBR": null, "DNBR_requirement": "not established", "limits": [ "rod-to-rod contact and load redistribution", "grid strap interference", "spring/dimple travel/yield", "local cladding contact stress", "coolant/internal-pressure stresses", "pellet interaction", "creep and irradiation constitutive response", "thermal gradients" ], "added_axial_integration_point_stress_MPa": 0.0, "thermal_references": [ { "test": "166-9", "p_MPa": 16.5474175036032, "inlet_C": 295.0, "mass_flux_kg_m2s": 2759.927844455419, "measured_CHF_MW_m2": 1.1703531664183908, "author_critical_power_MW": 2.5226, "geometry": "straight", "classification": "Published experimental/simulation reference", "source_url": "https://github.com/roman-mukin/HTRF-rod-bowing/tree/54121540d80e6d587d17b801b369b5fc9b56c6e1", "illustrative_reference_scaling_index": 1.3971737056957163, "index_classification": "Unvalidated transferred estimate; not study DNBR" }, { "test": "166-8", "p_MPa": 16.5474175036032, "inlet_C": 291.3333333333333, "mass_flux_kg_m2s": 3349.8878505183707, "measured_CHF_MW_m2": 1.3785561555925523, "author_critical_power_MW": 2.9714, "geometry": "straight", "classification": "Published experimental/simulation reference", "source_url": "https://github.com/roman-mukin/HTRF-rod-bowing/tree/54121540d80e6d587d17b801b369b5fc9b56c6e1", "illustrative_reference_scaling_index": 1.6457275185688092, "index_classification": "Unvalidated transferred estimate; not study DNBR" }, { "test": "166-7", "p_MPa": 14.4789903156528, "inlet_C": 294.6111111111111, "mass_flux_kg_m2s": 3356.6690000133476, "measured_CHF_MW_m2": 1.1987444831239584, "author_critical_power_MW": 2.5838, "geometry": "straight", "classification": "Published experimental/simulation reference", "source_url": "https://github.com/roman-mukin/HTRF-rod-bowing/tree/54121540d80e6d587d17b801b369b5fc9b56c6e1", "illustrative_reference_scaling_index": 1.431067407451138, "index_classification": "Unvalidated transferred estimate; not study DNBR" } ], "thermal_transfer_limit": "HTRF 85% closure is a disclosed proxy for 80%. Preserve all source P/T/G and geometry differences. Report both contact arrangements separately.", "nominal_study_heat_flux_W_m2": 837657.5952205018 }, "softened-050": { "id": "softened-050", "classification": "Native calculation with provisional inputs", "closure_percent": 50, "stiffness_N_per_mm": 20, "elements": 100, "native_complete": true, "finite_fields": true, "deck_sha256": "1a14b6ad329d716d9deac5a5d5f13d2caf5392e3a0a8cd0520ff36551d534b61", "native_files": { "dat": "e2e50ba8b8ff1bfae5cdf13b09913c2e04a293e883a68c4f514cccbf6a67f389", "sta": "01e324ec0ea28f4d1fd7f5e2da1277af53812b873e218be1604c17a4c8e4990d", "frd": "32e9952efb7a9c5b1a87404f6238597ad4619b43c11f51d41f691248fc1b230d" }, "midpoint_displacement_mm": 1.55, "midpoint_error_mm": 0.0, "minimum_nodal_gap_mm": 1.55, "gap_target_error_mm": 0.0, "grid_anchor_reaction_x_N": -31.0, "grid_force_magnitude_N": 31.0, "printed_midpoint_RF_x_N": 0.9215696, "actuator_reaction_x_N": null, "global_equilibrium_status": "not established", "end_reactions_x_N": [ -0.4607848, -0.4607848 ], "total_force_x_N": -31.000000000610665, "force_balance_relative": 0.943880540575571, "spring_check_absolute_N": 0.0, "spring_check_relative": 0.0, "maximum_absolute_axial_integration_point_stress_MPa": 6.406824, "stress_points": 1600, "contact_pressure": null, "DNBR": null, "DNBR_requirement": "not established", "limits": [ "rod-to-rod contact and load redistribution", "grid strap interference", "spring/dimple travel/yield", "local cladding contact stress", "coolant/internal-pressure stresses", "pellet interaction", "creep and irradiation constitutive response", "thermal gradients" ], "added_axial_integration_point_stress_MPa": 6.406824, "thermal_references": [ { "test": "170-4", "p_MPa": 16.65083886300072, "inlet_C": 292.8333333333333, "mass_flux_kg_m2s": 2713.816027889579, "measured_CHF_MW_m2": 1.1356526682226975, "author_critical_power_MW": 2.4478, "geometry": "partial bow, 50 percent remaining gap", "classification": "Published experimental/simulation reference", "source_url": "https://github.com/roman-mukin/HTRF-rod-bowing/tree/54121540d80e6d587d17b801b369b5fc9b56c6e1", "illustrative_reference_scaling_index": 1.3557480702168678, "index_classification": "Unvalidated transferred estimate; not study DNBR" }, { "test": "170-5", "p_MPa": 16.512943717137357, "inlet_C": 293.8333333333333, "mass_flux_kg_m2s": 3374.2999887002857, "measured_CHF_MW_m2": 1.3249281129264803, "author_critical_power_MW": 2.8558, "geometry": "partial bow, 50 percent remaining gap", "classification": "Published experimental/simulation reference", "source_url": "https://github.com/roman-mukin/HTRF-rod-bowing/tree/54121540d80e6d587d17b801b369b5fc9b56c6e1", "illustrative_reference_scaling_index": 1.581706081919679, "index_classification": "Unvalidated transferred estimate; not study DNBR" }, { "test": "170-6", "p_MPa": 14.4789903156528, "inlet_C": 296.1666666666667, "mass_flux_kg_m2s": 3359.3814598113377, "measured_CHF_MW_m2": 1.2113628461042107, "author_critical_power_MW": 2.611, "geometry": "partial bow, 50 percent remaining gap", "classification": "Published experimental/simulation reference", "source_url": "https://github.com/roman-mukin/HTRF-rod-bowing/tree/54121540d80e6d587d17b801b369b5fc9b56c6e1", "illustrative_reference_scaling_index": 1.4461312748979924, "index_classification": "Unvalidated transferred estimate; not study DNBR" } ], "thermal_transfer_limit": "HTRF 85% closure is a disclosed proxy for 80%. Preserve all source P/T/G and geometry differences. Report both contact arrangements separately.", "nominal_study_heat_flux_W_m2": 837657.5952205018 }, "softened-080": { "id": "softened-080", "classification": "Native calculation with provisional inputs", "closure_percent": 80, "stiffness_N_per_mm": 20, "elements": 100, "native_complete": true, "finite_fields": true, "deck_sha256": "f9860e4b276b192ea4a4ec25f5ffb6e84f264249ad9efe3725acffc9ff17a691", "native_files": { "dat": "b41c21536acd40e0d737b6011b3973c788199ae06c04bf1c283a85ce27a885cc", "sta": "01e324ec0ea28f4d1fd7f5e2da1277af53812b873e218be1604c17a4c8e4990d", "frd": "2a6c6b7e40c2e811e4a84cbf582e2d3bebdefc435d7cfb7b77fcebf071ddb193" }, "midpoint_displacement_mm": 2.48, "midpoint_error_mm": 0.0, "minimum_nodal_gap_mm": 0.6200000000000001, "gap_target_error_mm": 0.0, "grid_anchor_reaction_x_N": -49.6, "grid_force_magnitude_N": 49.6, "printed_midpoint_RF_x_N": 1.474511, "actuator_reaction_x_N": null, "global_equilibrium_status": "not established", "end_reactions_x_N": [ -0.7372557, -0.7372557 ], "total_force_x_N": -49.60000040181621, "force_balance_relative": 0.943880553969855, "spring_check_absolute_N": 0.0, "spring_check_relative": 0.0, "maximum_absolute_axial_integration_point_stress_MPa": 10.25092, "stress_points": 1600, "contact_pressure": null, "DNBR": null, "DNBR_requirement": "not established", "limits": [ "rod-to-rod contact and load redistribution", "grid strap interference", "spring/dimple travel/yield", "local cladding contact stress", "coolant/internal-pressure stresses", "pellet interaction", "creep and irradiation constitutive response", "thermal gradients" ], "added_axial_integration_point_stress_MPa": 10.25092, "thermal_references": [ { "test": "169-6", "p_MPa": 16.5474175036032, "inlet_C": 292.3333333333333, "mass_flux_kg_m2s": 2991.843157183614, "measured_CHF_MW_m2": 1.154580212693076, "author_critical_power_MW": 2.4886, "geometry": "partial bow, 15 percent remaining gap", "classification": "Published experimental/simulation reference", "source_url": "https://github.com/roman-mukin/HTRF-rod-bowing/tree/54121540d80e6d587d17b801b369b5fc9b56c6e1", "illustrative_reference_scaling_index": 1.3783438713871492, "index_classification": "Unvalidated transferred estimate; not study DNBR" }, { "test": "169-8", "p_MPa": 14.58241167505032, "inlet_C": 293.72222222222223, "mass_flux_kg_m2s": 3382.4373680942576, "measured_CHF_MW_m2": 1.2018990738690214, "author_critical_power_MW": 2.5906, "geometry": "partial bow, 15 percent remaining gap", "classification": "Published experimental/simulation reference", "source_url": "https://github.com/roman-mukin/HTRF-rod-bowing/tree/54121540d80e6d587d17b801b369b5fc9b56c6e1", "illustrative_reference_scaling_index": 1.4348333743128516, "index_classification": "Unvalidated transferred estimate; not study DNBR" }, { "test": "169-7", "p_MPa": 16.58189129006904, "inlet_C": 295.27777777777777, "mass_flux_kg_m2s": 3397.355896983206, "measured_CHF_MW_m2": 1.306000568456102, "author_critical_power_MW": 2.815, "geometry": "partial bow, 15 percent remaining gap", "classification": "Published experimental/simulation reference", "source_url": "https://github.com/roman-mukin/HTRF-rod-bowing/tree/54121540d80e6d587d17b801b369b5fc9b56c6e1", "illustrative_reference_scaling_index": 1.5591102807493977, "index_classification": "Unvalidated transferred estimate; not study DNBR" } ], "thermal_transfer_limit": "HTRF 85% closure is a disclosed proxy for 80%. Preserve all source P/T/G and geometry differences. Report both contact arrangements separately.", "nominal_study_heat_flux_W_m2": 837657.5952205018 }, "softened-100": { "id": "softened-100", "classification": "Native calculation with provisional inputs", "closure_percent": 100, "stiffness_N_per_mm": 20, "elements": 100, "native_complete": true, "finite_fields": true, "deck_sha256": "4e9f0f4e2306ceaf4172c6e598ad02ec1cda115350526dba5e237e8b2f7ab473", "native_files": { "dat": "fcef00080733ec77019046cb14b47b0fc11e50272275e6f74290cb31ffebabf2", "sta": "01e324ec0ea28f4d1fd7f5e2da1277af53812b873e218be1604c17a4c8e4990d", "frd": "39c268b8770478b6b019382847529ece3f30819d545037bb53d80577a89dc281" }, "midpoint_displacement_mm": 3.1, "midpoint_error_mm": 0.0, "minimum_nodal_gap_mm": 0.0, "gap_target_error_mm": 0.0, "grid_anchor_reaction_x_N": -62.0, "grid_force_magnitude_N": 62.0, "printed_midpoint_RF_x_N": 1.843139, "actuator_reaction_x_N": null, "global_equilibrium_status": "not established", "end_reactions_x_N": [ -0.9215696, -0.9215696 ], "total_force_x_N": -62.00000020122133, "force_balance_relative": 0.9438805464942518, "spring_check_absolute_N": 0.0, "spring_check_relative": 0.0, "maximum_absolute_axial_integration_point_stress_MPa": 12.81365, "stress_points": 1600, "contact_pressure": null, "DNBR": null, "DNBR_requirement": "not established", "limits": [ "rod-to-rod contact and load redistribution", "grid strap interference", "spring/dimple travel/yield", "local cladding contact stress", "coolant/internal-pressure stresses", "pellet interaction", "creep and irradiation constitutive response", "thermal gradients" ], "added_axial_integration_point_stress_MPa": 12.81365, "thermal_references": [ { "test": "167-5", "p_MPa": 16.5474175036032, "inlet_C": 291.3888888888889, "mass_flux_kg_m2s": 2750.434235162452, "measured_CHF_MW_m2": 0.9621501772442297, "author_critical_power_MW": 2.0738, "geometry": "contact arrangement 167", "classification": "Published experimental/simulation reference", "source_url": "https://github.com/roman-mukin/HTRF-rod-bowing/tree/54121540d80e6d587d17b801b369b5fc9b56c6e1", "illustrative_reference_scaling_index": 1.1486198928226241, "index_classification": "Unvalidated transferred estimate; not study DNBR" }, { "test": "167-6", "p_MPa": 16.5474175036032, "inlet_C": 288.0, "mass_flux_kg_m2s": 3465.16739193297, "measured_CHF_MW_m2": 1.100952170027004, "author_critical_power_MW": 2.373, "geometry": "contact arrangement 167", "classification": "Published experimental/simulation reference", "source_url": "https://github.com/roman-mukin/HTRF-rod-bowing/tree/54121540d80e6d587d17b801b369b5fc9b56c6e1", "illustrative_reference_scaling_index": 1.314322434738019, "index_classification": "Unvalidated transferred estimate; not study DNBR" }, { "test": "167-7", "p_MPa": 14.4789903156528, "inlet_C": 297.6111111111111, "mass_flux_kg_m2s": 3378.368678397272, "measured_CHF_MW_m2": 1.1451164404578869, "author_critical_power_MW": 2.4682, "geometry": "contact arrangement 167", "classification": "Published experimental/simulation reference", "source_url": "https://github.com/roman-mukin/HTRF-rod-bowing/tree/54121540d80e6d587d17b801b369b5fc9b56c6e1", "illustrative_reference_scaling_index": 1.3670459708020086, "index_classification": "Unvalidated transferred estimate; not study DNBR" }, { "test": "168-5", "p_MPa": 16.58189129006904, "inlet_C": 295.05555555555554, "mass_flux_kg_m2s": 2753.146694960442, "measured_CHF_MW_m2": 0.9558409957541036, "author_critical_power_MW": 2.0602, "geometry": "contact arrangement 168", "classification": "Published experimental/simulation reference", "source_url": "https://github.com/roman-mukin/HTRF-rod-bowing/tree/54121540d80e6d587d17b801b369b5fc9b56c6e1", "illustrative_reference_scaling_index": 1.141087959099197, "index_classification": "Unvalidated transferred estimate; not study DNBR" }, { "test": "168-8", "p_MPa": 14.4789903156528, "inlet_C": 293.1111111111111, "mass_flux_kg_m2s": 3383.7935979932527, "measured_CHF_MW_m2": 1.233444981319652, "author_critical_power_MW": 2.6586, "geometry": "contact arrangement 168", "classification": "Published experimental/simulation reference", "source_url": "https://github.com/roman-mukin/HTRF-rod-bowing/tree/54121540d80e6d587d17b801b369b5fc9b56c6e1", "illustrative_reference_scaling_index": 1.472493042929987, "index_classification": "Unvalidated transferred estimate; not study DNBR" }, { "test": "168-6", "p_MPa": 16.5474175036032, "inlet_C": 293.77777777777777, "mass_flux_kg_m2s": 3401.4245866801916, "measured_CHF_MW_m2": 1.0914883977918148, "author_critical_power_MW": 2.3526, "geometry": "contact arrangement 168", "classification": "Published experimental/simulation reference", "source_url": "https://github.com/roman-mukin/HTRF-rod-bowing/tree/54121540d80e6d587d17b801b369b5fc9b56c6e1", "illustrative_reference_scaling_index": 1.3030245341528786, "index_classification": "Unvalidated transferred estimate; not study DNBR" } ], "thermal_transfer_limit": "HTRF 85% closure is a disclosed proxy for 80%. Preserve all source P/T/G and geometry differences. Report both contact arrangements separately.", "nominal_study_heat_flux_W_m2": 837657.5952205018 } }, "case_count": 8, "checks": [ { "id": "fresh-000-complete", "observed": true, "passed": true }, { "id": "fresh-000-displacement", "observed": 0.0, "limit": 1e-05, "passed": true }, { "id": "fresh-000-gap", "observed": 0.0, "limit": 1e-05, "passed": true }, { "id": "fresh-000-balance", "observed": 0.0, "limit": 0.001, "passed": true }, { "id": "fresh-000-spring", "observed": 0.0, "limit": 0.001, "passed": true }, { "id": "fresh-050-complete", "observed": true, "passed": true }, { "id": "fresh-050-displacement", "observed": 0.0, "limit": 1e-05, "passed": true }, { "id": "fresh-050-gap", "observed": 0.0, "limit": 1e-05, "passed": true }, { "id": "fresh-050-balance", "observed": 0.976770024013072, "limit": 0.001, "passed": false }, { "id": "fresh-050-spring", "observed": 0.0, "limit": 0.001, "passed": true }, { "id": "fresh-080-complete", "observed": true, "passed": true }, { "id": "fresh-080-displacement", "observed": 0.0, "limit": 1e-05, "passed": true }, { "id": "fresh-080-gap", "observed": 0.0, "limit": 1e-05, "passed": true }, { "id": "fresh-080-balance", "observed": 0.9767700296406471, "limit": 0.001, "passed": false }, { "id": "fresh-080-spring", "observed": 0.0, "limit": 0.001, "passed": true }, { "id": "fresh-100-complete", "observed": true, "passed": true }, { "id": "fresh-100-displacement", "observed": 0.0, "limit": 1e-05, "passed": true }, { "id": "fresh-100-gap", "observed": 0.0, "limit": 1e-05, "passed": true }, { "id": "fresh-100-balance", "observed": 0.9767700265044909, "limit": 0.001, "passed": false }, { "id": "fresh-100-spring", "observed": 0.0, "limit": 0.001, "passed": true }, { "id": "softened-000-complete", "observed": true, "passed": true }, { "id": "softened-000-displacement", "observed": 0.0, "limit": 1e-05, "passed": true }, { "id": "softened-000-gap", "observed": 0.0, "limit": 1e-05, "passed": true }, { "id": "softened-000-balance", "observed": 0.0, "limit": 0.001, "passed": true }, { "id": "softened-000-spring", "observed": 0.0, "limit": 0.001, "passed": true }, { "id": "softened-050-complete", "observed": true, "passed": true }, { "id": "softened-050-displacement", "observed": 0.0, "limit": 1e-05, "passed": true }, { "id": "softened-050-gap", "observed": 0.0, "limit": 1e-05, "passed": true }, { "id": "softened-050-balance", "observed": 0.943880540575571, "limit": 0.001, "passed": false }, { "id": "softened-050-spring", "observed": 0.0, "limit": 0.001, "passed": true }, { "id": "softened-080-complete", "observed": true, "passed": true }, { "id": "softened-080-displacement", "observed": 0.0, "limit": 1e-05, "passed": true }, { "id": "softened-080-gap", "observed": 0.0, "limit": 1e-05, "passed": true }, { "id": "softened-080-balance", "observed": 0.943880553969855, "limit": 0.001, "passed": false }, { "id": "softened-080-spring", "observed": 0.0, "limit": 0.001, "passed": true }, { "id": "softened-100-complete", "observed": true, "passed": true }, { "id": "softened-100-displacement", "observed": 0.0, "limit": 1e-05, "passed": true }, { "id": "softened-100-gap", "observed": 0.0, "limit": 1e-05, "passed": true }, { "id": "softened-100-balance", "observed": 0.9438805464942518, "limit": 0.001, "passed": false }, { "id": "softened-100-spring", "observed": 0.0, "limit": 0.001, "passed": true } ], "all_numerical_checks_pass": false, "literature_source": "https://github.com/roman-mukin/HTRF-rod-bowing/tree/54121540d80e6d587d17b801b369b5fc9b56c6e1", "DNBR_requirement": "not established", "EOL": { "scope": "Proposal arithmetic for engineer review only; not a study result or calibrated grid prediction", "model_card": "basis/eol-reference-model-proposal-r1.json", "reference_fluence_n_m2": 6e+24, "published_fit_stress_ratio": 0.5021626470260343, "unity_anchored_alternative_ratio": 0.5488116360940265, "slope_sensitivity_not_confidence_interval": [ { "slope_m2_n": 7.5e-26, "ratio": 0.5834297587339227 }, { "slope_m2_n": 1e-25, "ratio": 0.5021626470260343 }, { "slope_m2_n": 1.25e-25, "ratio": 0.43221539575802853 } ], "exposure_duration_days_if_flux_is_constant_within_source_range": [ 385.8024691358025, 462.962962962963 ], "conditional_preload_mapping_N": { "spring": 2.5108132351301715, "dimple_1": 1.2554066175650858, "dimple_2": 1.2554066175650858 }, "limitations": "Extra numerical digits support reproducibility, not empirical precision. Time bounds are derived equivalent exposures, not observed operating dates." }, "retained_bulk_properties": { "recorded_at": "2026-10-16T14:47:28.305482+00:00", "classification": "Conditional pre-A global heat/enthalpy screen; unaccepted geometry/power assumptions. Not local CFD, pilot acceptance or a DNBR result.", "conditions": { "recorded_at": "2026-10-16T14:43:48.412361+00:00", "classification": "Conditional pre-A whole-bundle energy/property screen, not accepted basis or case CFD/DNBR.", "equations": [ "A_open = enclosure_width\u00b2 - 25*pi*rod_OD\u00b2/4", "m_dot = supplied_G * A_open", "Q = 25 * proposed_rod_linear_power * proposed_length", "h_out = actual_MCP_h_in + Q/m_dot" ], "supplied": { "rod_OD_m": 0.0095, "mass_flux_kg_m2_s": 3000, "pressure_Pa": 15500000, "inlet_temperature_K": 563.15, "bowed_rod_linear_power_W_m": 25000 }, "proposed": { "enclosure_inside_width_m": 0.063, "all_25_rods_at_supplied_bowed_rod_linear_power": true, "lengths_m": [ 0.5, 1.0, 1.5 ], "pressure_constant": true, "adiabatic_enclosure": true, "inlet_away_from_grid": true, "steady_no_storage_or_work": true }, "derived": { "open_inlet_area_m2": 0.0021969453938345076, "mass_flow_kg_s": 6.590836181503523, "nominal_per_rod_mean_heat_flux_W_m2": 837657.5952205018 }, "reused_inlet_run_id": "4ac275dfa69547b0946ebb83951ceb22", "inlet_sources": { "heos": { "path": "qualification/water-basis-r1/inlet_heos.json", "sha256": "5a74291a0cb9939b884e5adcab86cbf71e97efd47b8f63ac8830c02ed6c082ae" }, "if97": { "path": "qualification/water-basis-r1/inlet_if97.json", "sha256": "dfecba202a829309ece0e9414a9648c9367c2fcb6f1b9c1c2af7b674b90b3511" } }, "requests": [ { "id": "heos_length_500", "backend": "heos", "length_m": 0.5, "total_power_W": 312500.0, "mass_flow_kg_s": 6.590836181503523, "enthalpy_rise_J_kg": 47414.31760616321, "arguments": { "fluid": "Water", "input1_key": "P", "input1_value": 15500000, "input2_key": "H", "input2_value": 1331811.8770273703 } }, { "id": "if97_length_500", "backend": "if97", "length_m": 0.5, "total_power_W": 312500.0, "mass_flow_kg_s": 6.590836181503523, "enthalpy_rise_J_kg": 47414.31760616321, "arguments": { "fluid": "IF97::Water", "input1_key": "P", "input1_value": 15500000, "input2_key": "H", "input2_value": 1331580.7778922976 } }, { "id": "heos_length_1000", "backend": "heos", "length_m": 1.0, "total_power_W": 625000.0, "mass_flow_kg_s": 6.590836181503523, "enthalpy_rise_J_kg": 94828.63521232642, "arguments": { "fluid": "Water", "input1_key": "P", "input1_value": 15500000, "input2_key": "H", "input2_value": 1379226.1946335335 } }, { "id": "if97_length_1000", "backend": "if97", "length_m": 1.0, "total_power_W": 625000.0, "mass_flow_kg_s": 6.590836181503523, "enthalpy_rise_J_kg": 94828.63521232642, "arguments": { "fluid": "IF97::Water", "input1_key": "P", "input1_value": 15500000, "input2_key": "H", "input2_value": 1378995.0954984608 } }, { "id": "heos_length_1500", "backend": "heos", "length_m": 1.5, "total_power_W": 937500.0, "mass_flow_kg_s": 6.590836181503523, "enthalpy_rise_J_kg": 142242.95281848963, "arguments": { "fluid": "Water", "input1_key": "P", "input1_value": 15500000, "input2_key": "H", "input2_value": 1426640.5122396967 } }, { "id": "if97_length_1500", "backend": "if97", "length_m": 1.5, "total_power_W": 937500.0, "mass_flow_kg_s": 6.590836181503523, "enthalpy_rise_J_kg": 142242.95281848963, "arguments": { "fluid": "IF97::Water", "input1_key": "P", "input1_value": 15500000, "input2_key": "H", "input2_value": 1426409.413104624 } } ], "limits": [ "Global mixing/enthalpy accounting only. No local flow redistribution, surface temperatures, rod contact, grid losses, pressure drop, boiling onset or CHF.", "Same library with different HEOS/IF97 formulations is a consistency comparison, not independent experimental validation.", "Only bowed-rod linear power is supplied; other rods/length/enclosure are unaccepted proposals.", "A subcooled bulk estimate cannot establish local single-phase flow or DNBR applicability." ] }, "results": [ { "id": "heos_length_500", "backend": "heos", "length_m": 0.5, "total_power_W": 312500.0, "mass_flow_kg_s": 6.590836181503523, "enthalpy_rise_J_kg": 47414.31760616321, "outlet_temperature_K": 572.0388074717588, "outlet_temperature_degC": 298.8888074717588, "saturation_temperature_degC": 344.78941524101106, "bulk_subcooling_K": 45.90060776925225, "equilibrium_enthalpy_quality": -0.3084828707786964, "actual_vapor_quality": null, "phase": "liquid", "artifact_path": "qualification/water-basis-r1/heos_length_500.json", "sha256": "81297097b92ce37dace4b0f26c3efcdacb7ebf0beb6435d2902ca8b3ee8d352e" }, { "id": "if97_length_500", "backend": "if97", "length_m": 0.5, "total_power_W": 312500.0, "mass_flow_kg_s": 6.590836181503523, "enthalpy_rise_J_kg": 47414.31760616321, "outlet_temperature_K": 572.0465721361265, "outlet_temperature_degC": 298.89657213612657, "saturation_temperature_degC": 344.7915516035491, "bulk_subcooling_K": 45.89497946742256, "equilibrium_enthalpy_quality": -0.30865054367114486, "actual_vapor_quality": null, "phase": "liquid", "artifact_path": "qualification/water-basis-r1/if97_length_500.json", "sha256": "d607ce103e9453680d19fcf43d4178a6f007e1935abd259a2c845eb9c34648ad" }, { "id": "heos_length_1000", "backend": "heos", "length_m": 1.0, "total_power_W": 625000.0, "mass_flow_kg_s": 6.590836181503523, "enthalpy_rise_J_kg": 94828.63521232642, "outlet_temperature_K": 580.5960009868957, "outlet_temperature_degC": 307.4460009868957, "saturation_temperature_degC": 344.78941524101106, "bulk_subcooling_K": 37.34341425411537, "equilibrium_enthalpy_quality": -0.2594118544793941, "actual_vapor_quality": null, "phase": "liquid", "artifact_path": "qualification/water-basis-r1/heos_length_1000.json", "sha256": "f1b3c6f04de7ed56380dcf57aa5faf47f347f0bd7d4df98efd7c61d2a3a330ab" }, { "id": "if97_length_1000", "backend": "if97", "length_m": 1.0, "total_power_W": 625000.0, "mass_flow_kg_s": 6.590836181503523, "enthalpy_rise_J_kg": 94828.63521232642, "outlet_temperature_K": 580.608162347896, "outlet_temperature_degC": 307.45816234789606, "saturation_temperature_degC": 344.7915516035491, "bulk_subcooling_K": 37.33338925565306, "equilibrium_enthalpy_quality": -0.2595860102534558, "actual_vapor_quality": null, "phase": "liquid", "artifact_path": "qualification/water-basis-r1/if97_length_1000.json", "sha256": "29d80254cff54db9d24997cc4267f2732f1fdc04c0ca8dc2b567767419a3812b" }, { "id": "heos_length_1500", "backend": "heos", "length_m": 1.5, "total_power_W": 937500.0, "mass_flow_kg_s": 6.590836181503523, "enthalpy_rise_J_kg": 142242.95281848963, "outlet_temperature_K": 588.7759686910199, "outlet_temperature_degC": 315.6259686910199, "saturation_temperature_degC": 344.78941524101106, "bulk_subcooling_K": 29.163446549991136, "equilibrium_enthalpy_quality": -0.21034083818009172, "actual_vapor_quality": null, "phase": "liquid", "artifact_path": "qualification/water-basis-r1/heos_length_1500.json", "sha256": "857c1fb07508cec2696fd29db67a064abe3ad0d6479b885cb25e362db40c875d" }, { "id": "if97_length_1500", "backend": "if97", "length_m": 1.5, "total_power_W": 937500.0, "mass_flow_kg_s": 6.590836181503523, "enthalpy_rise_J_kg": 142242.95281848963, "outlet_temperature_K": 588.787612207698, "outlet_temperature_degC": 315.637612207698, "saturation_temperature_degC": 344.7915516035491, "bulk_subcooling_K": 29.153939395851125, "equilibrium_enthalpy_quality": -0.2105214768357667, "actual_vapor_quality": null, "phase": "liquid", "artifact_path": "qualification/water-basis-r1/if97_length_1500.json", "sha256": "69ee76a53a7f691b3005b99be9fe7b5609153089caec8c4ec8632e402002273a" } ], "backend_consistency": [ { "length_m": 0.5, "IF97_minus_HEOS_outlet_temperature_K": 0.007764664367755358 }, { "length_m": 1, "IF97_minus_HEOS_outlet_temperature_K": 0.012161361000380566 }, { "length_m": 1.5, "IF97_minus_HEOS_outlet_temperature_K": 0.011643516678077503 } ], "reused_HEOS_saturation": "evidence/coolprop-runtime-saturation-r1.json", "native_property_runs": [ { "run_id": "4ac275dfa69547b0946ebb83951ceb22", "state": "completed", "started_at": "2026-10-16T14:41:19.103993+00:00", "completed_at": "2026-10-16T14:41:33.981749+00:00", "duration_s": 14.877756 }, { "run_id": "13453c8c10544f8fbf40e34f3dbd561a", "state": "completed", "started_at": "2026-10-16T14:44:02.688862+00:00", "completed_at": "2026-10-16T14:44:12.163083+00:00", "duration_s": 9.474221 } ], "raw_files": [ { "path": "qualification/water-basis-r1/heos_length_500.json", "sha256": "81297097b92ce37dace4b0f26c3efcdacb7ebf0beb6435d2902ca8b3ee8d352e", "bytes": 598 }, { "path": "qualification/water-basis-r1/if97_length_500.json", "sha256": "d607ce103e9453680d19fcf43d4178a6f007e1935abd259a2c845eb9c34648ad", "bytes": 587 }, { "path": "qualification/water-basis-r1/heos_length_1000.json", "sha256": "f1b3c6f04de7ed56380dcf57aa5faf47f347f0bd7d4df98efd7c61d2a3a330ab", "bytes": 592 }, { "path": "qualification/water-basis-r1/if97_length_1000.json", "sha256": "29d80254cff54db9d24997cc4267f2732f1fdc04c0ca8dc2b567767419a3812b", "bytes": 589 }, { "path": "qualification/water-basis-r1/heos_length_1500.json", "sha256": "857c1fb07508cec2696fd29db67a064abe3ad0d6479b885cb25e362db40c875d", "bytes": 597 }, { "path": "qualification/water-basis-r1/if97_length_1500.json", "sha256": "69ee76a53a7f691b3005b99be9fe7b5609153089caec8c4ec8632e402002273a", "bytes": 587 } ], "completed_native_property_calls": 9, "native_spatial_solver_runs": 0, "provider": "Unchanged JerryMansikkaviita/CoolpropMCP 6e446f0f57b3e88716bbed92adb0495af32a44c9; CoolProp 8.0.0", "observation_limits": [ "Required T/P/density/enthalpy fields are finite; null optional IF97 compressibility factor remains null.", "Native vapor quality is undefined/null in these single-phase states. The negative equilibrium enthalpy coordinate is not a negative vapor mass fraction.", "HEOS/IF97 agreement in one library is formulation consistency, not independent experimental validation.", "A subcooled bundle-average state does not establish local subchannel states, wall boiling, heat transfer coefficient, contact/grid effects or CHF applicability.", "Other-rod power, span, enclosure, constant pressure and adiabatic steady energy assumptions are proposals.", "No local flow field or heat-transfer correlation was implemented. Existing solver properties and native CHF method remain unresolved." ], "method_implication": "Consider supported pre-CHF/subcooled methods; do not require a full two-phase spatial simulation solely because DNBR is requested. Selection still requires an existing applicable CHF implementation, compatible local fields and a relevant contact/bow/grid benchmark with uncertainty.", "checkpoints": { "A": "Not submitted/accepted", "B": "Not accepted", "C": "Not accepted" }, "main_study_run": null, "public_release": false }, "engineering_acceptance": false }